PHS Student Journalists on 'Fantasy League'

This week's issue of The Piedmont Highlander features an investigation into the "Fantasy Slut League" by the student newspaper's editorial board.

Students at Piedmont High School think the so-called "Fantasy Slut League" run by some male varsity athletes was degrading — but not nearly as bad as media reports and a letter to parents from PHS Principal Rich Kitchens made it sound, according to an article in this week's issue of the school newspaper, The Piedmont Highlander. 

The fantasy league — modeled on fantasy football leagues, but featuring female students — attracted international attention after Piedmont Patch and other media learned of Kitchens' letter to parents of all PHS students last month. In that letter, Kitchens wrote, "It has been reported that students on some of our Varsity Teams have set up a "Fantasy Slut League" in which our female students (unbeknownst to most of them) are drafted as part of the league. Male students earn points for documented engagement in sexual activities with female students."

Members of the Highlander's editorial board reported that they interviewed Kitchens, 25 sophomore, junor and senior girls, and eight junior and senior boys, including five who participated in the FSL. The students who were interviewed were not identified by name.

"Although most girls said they thought the league was degrading, wrong and mistreating, they said the letter exaggerated certain aspects of the league," according to the Highlander article. 

The article said most of the girls interviewed said casual sex is uncommon at PHS and that "hooking up" did not necessarily mean sexual intercourse. The majority of girls interviewed also said that "guys do not give girls alcohol with the intent of hooking up with them."

The Highlander quotes one male athlete who participated in the FSL as saying, "There weren’t a whole lot of victims because nobody did anything out of line in terms of going out and hooking up with someone just because they wanted points. All that we did was document information.”

Another male participant said, "I want the student body to know that there are boys who feel sorry for what happened, but we’re learning from it. Sometimes it takes mistakes to learn how to be better.”

Male athletes told the Highlander that "hook-ups" were reported verbally and posted on a Facebook group wall as documentation.

Highlander editorial board members said they interviewed Kitchens about specific points in his letter.

Kitchens told them he gathered information on the FSL by interviewing male athletes, some of them multiple times.

"Kitchens said while some students were forthcoming, others lied and deceived," according to the Highlander article.

The student journalists said they also asked Kitchens why he wrote to parents before addressing the student body on the issue.

“When I got this information, I felt compelled to share it,” the Highlander quotes Kitchens as saying. “It’s on the parents. It’s not for me to tell you how to act outside of school. It’s up to your parents, your family.”

You may read the complete article on The Piedmont Highlander's website.

Don't miss a day of Piedmont news, opinion and events. Sign up for the Piedmont Patch e-newsletter here.

C. Caufield November 01, 2012 at 09:02 PM
PHS is ignoring its responsibility by not teaching the students involved in the FSL that there are consequences to their actions. The discussion about whether the description of the FSL has been exaggerated is not the key issue. At the very least, the fact that the boys refer to girls as "sluts", regardless of the level of sexual activity, is sexual harassment (if you disagree, look on the EEOC website). Also to say no one felt pressured is to ignore typical teenage development regarding the desire to fit in. Of course kids make mistakes but mistakes still have consequences. We are talking about young people, many of whom can vote in this election, who knew better and chose to ignored it. Compared to most, the kids in Piedmont are very privileged, and they need to learn that with privilege comes more, not less, responsibility. Lastly it has been said that it was primarily varsity athletes who participated in the FSL. So, as a mother of a Division I athlete, I can tell those who want to play college sports that behavior such as they have displayed will result in actions by their coach, athletic department or school.
junior girl December 05, 2012 at 04:49 AM
well, when we tell you that girls set up leagues too, what do you think? and as a girl that was drafted, i can tell you that when we hook up, mainly just kissing. and i'm glad to hear that student athletes at div 1 schools are all saints. tell that to the poor girl that was raped by the LAX player at UVA. some boys are stupid and bad, but the boys at PHS rock and don't pressure anyone to do anything. girls did the leagues to have something to talk about. boys did leagues for the same reason. no one ever pressured anyone to do anything. piedmont girls are smart and empowered and don't need your lecturing us about consequences


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »